The purpose of law and how it creates justice are two sides of the same coin, and there’s a lot of debate within legal philosophy about how exactly they work together. Here’s a breakdown of the two main purposes of law and how they connect to justice:
1. Maintaining Order and Establishing Standards
Laws set clear expectations for behavior. This helps people know what is acceptable and unacceptable, reducing conflict and creating a predictable environment. Laws also establish minimum standards for things like safety, health, and fair dealing. This protects people from harm and exploitation.
Justice Connection: By creating order and standards, the law promotes a sense of fairness and predictability. People can rely on the law to be treated equally and to have recourse if wronged.
2. Resolving Disputes and Protecting Liberties
Laws provide a framework for settling disagreements fairly and peacefully. This avoids chaos and violence from personal vendettas. Laws also protect fundamental rights and liberties, ensuring everyone has a chance to participate in society and pursue their goals.
Justice Connection: A fair and accessible legal system allows people to vindicate their rights and get compensation for wrongs. This is a key aspect of achieving justice.
It’s important to note that there are different theories about how well law actually achieves justice. Here are two contrasting viewpoints:
Positivist view: Law and justice are separate. Laws are simply rules created by a society, and following them is what creates order, even if the laws themselves aren’t perfectly just.
Natural Law view: There’s a higher law based on reason or morality that true laws should reflect. A law that isn’t just isn’t really a law at all.
These are just some of the ways legal scholars think about the purpose of law and justice. It’s an ongoing conversation that grapples with complex questions about fairness, order, and the role of law in society.
Leave a Reply